These are trying times online.
That, at least, is one takeaway from the latest Pew Research Center study that surveyed over 1,500 tech and academic experts about the state of the Net and their view of its future.
Pew and Elon University asked:
In the next decade, will public discourse online become more or less shaped by bad actors, harassment, trolls, and an overall tone of griping, distrust, and disgust?
Remarkably, 81% responded that they expected things to remain the same (42%) or get worse (39%) while less than 1 in 5 thought that things would improve.
No less a figure than the “father of the Internet” and a Google VP, Vint Cerf responded: “The combination of bias-reinforcing enclaves and global access to bad actions seems like a toxic mix. It is not clear whether there is a way to counter-balance their socially harmful effects.”
These enclaves or “bubbles” as we’ve come to know them, played a big part in the recent US election – effectively separating users from posts or opinions that they did not share.
Paula Hooper Mayhew, a professor of humanities at Fairleigh Dickinson University, stated, “My fear is that because of the virtually unlimited opportunities for negative use of social media globally we will experience a rising worldwide demand for restrictive regulation. This response may work against support of free speech in the U.S.”
This is a fear shared by a number of the commentators – that many of the self-regulatory efforts to control bad actors have failed and will lead to more censorious legislation.
Taking a more positive note, however, technology entrepreneur, writer, and influencer, Esther Dyson wrote: “Things will get somewhat better because people will find it tougher to avoid accountability. Reputations will follow you more than they do now.”
She and others saw the rise of technology-based reputation systems and a shedding of anonymity as keys to a saner, more civil web. Dyson does warn, though, that anonymity will remain “necessary in regimes or cultures or simply situations where the truth is avoided and truth-speakers are punished.”
So how do we teach our kids and young people to treat each other fairly and respectfully when they see so many adults behaving badly? What should be our response when our teen makes up her own “alternate facts” about her classmates and spreads them online? How do you tell a young man not to denigrate a woman when some of our own political leaders use terms like “bimbo” or worse on Twitter?
I think we’re all going to have to dig deep and remind ourselves of our core principles and values – as parents, teachers and ordinary citizens. We will have some difficult and awkward conversations with our children and have to remind them about the Golden Rule and how it applies on and offline.
These next few years will present us all with many teachable moments. One positive outcome would be a return and a reminder of the basic values and principles that many of us learned in 5th grade civics class. That all men and women are created equal and thus should be treated with respect. And that beyond laws, our customs, norms and practices of basic human decency are the glue that holds our society together.
So, in that spirit, we stand ready and willing to work with this administration and Congress on a wide range of online safety issues – from revenge porn and online radicalization to the new world of connected toys and household devices.
We welcome the First Lady’s announcement that she will tackle cyberbullying as the focus of her efforts over the next four years. She could begin by drawing attention to the issue and to help raise awareness about the many resources that already exist while calling on the tech industry, educators, law enforcement, parents and the kids, themselves, to do more to counter bullying behavior online.
Machine learning tools such as Google’s Perspective, is a good example of the next wave of tech-inspired solutions to this growing problem. The innovative and energetic Project Rockit demonstrates how kids can be empowered in a school setting to lead with kindness and respect. And we’ll need the facts, figures and evidence provided by groups such as the Cyberbullying Research Center to ground our work and test our responses.
Finally, we hope that Mrs. Trump will help steer children and young people towards positive uses of technology and social media. And, just possibly, persuade her husband to think before he posts.